Fri 30 Apr 2010
Seeking Forgiveness: The Vatican’s Public Image Problem
Posted by boardroompr under Crisis Communications, Media, News / Reactions, Public Relations
No Comments
As Florida crisis communications consultants, Boardroom Communications comments on local, national and international crises in the public domain. Certainly, the sex abuse allegations and jury verdicts with the Catholic Church are nothing new, but as time goes on, it appears they have not fared well with their circle-the-wagons” strategy.
The Catholic Church is suffering an image crisis that shows no sign of abating. It seems that with each passing day, another sexual abuse case emerges, alleging the Church’s knowledge of, and in many cases, protection of pedophiles in their ranks by those in the highest of offices. Abuse allegations have been flooding out of Europe and more cases are coming to light out of the United States as well-most recently by a group of men from a school for the deaf in Wisconsin who allege that a priest preyed on as many as 200 of their classmates during his tenure there. The Church seems to be in a downward spiral, and may have already missed the opportunity to salvage at least a little bit of credibility and restore its public image.
One of the most important steps that the church should have taken in it’s crisis communications plan would have been to have the Pope himself, as the most public face of the organization, come forward and accept full responsibility for the actions of the abusers and for the organization that covered up their wrongdoing. Like any CEO of a public company, the Pope has “shareholders” to answer to-the millions of Catholics around the world who keep his organization afloat. And, like any company in a crisis situation, the Catholic Church should have acted quickly, decisively and humbly in a well-planned PR strategy, using one Vatican spokesperson to address the accusations.
The appointed spokesperson should have made public statements, spoken to the media and taken questions, and made plans to work on an ongoing basis with groups like SNAP (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests) and other sexual victims’ rights groups to show compassion and to amend past wrongs. Finally, the church should create a comprehensive plan to distribute throughout their parishes around the world about steps being taken to identify and weed out potential pedophiles among seminarians before they become priests, in order to avoid placing children in jeopardy. The church should map out additional safeguards in parish schools, youth groups and Sunday schools that would educate Catholic youths about their rights and protecting themselves from sexual predators. This type of crisis communication strategy would have made the public feel that the church was earnest and remorseful for the pain inflicted on so many innocent children and teens.
Instead, Vatican priests and bishops are unwisely making excuses, attributing the scandal to a smear campaign by the media, devil-possession and mere petty gossip, all of which marginalize the victims and make the church seem defensive and unrepentant. By not addressing this seriously and reflecting on the mistakes made in the past, the Catholic Church might be orchestrating its own downfall.




